Posted By: R Fusella, 27 October, 2015
My family & I have been customers of Fratelli's for 20 plus years. They never disappoint! By far, the best pizza in town, the "Grandma" pie being my favorite! Not to mention their Italian dishes are outstanding and delish! We all have our favorites. We're always greeted with a warm welcome and the owners make you feel like part of the family! Can't say enough, only that you give it a try!
The Fusella Family
Posted By: Allison Mitchell, 15 October, 2015
Fratelli's is family owned and family oriented and will certainly take care of your family. Whether it is a quick slice of pizza, a sit down dinner or a catered event, they are top notch. The service is great and the food is exceptional.
Posted By: Sal D., 28 September, 2015
I'm from Brooklyn so I know good pizza ;) and this is good pizza, great staff and great lunch specials
Posted By: John C., 10 July, 2015
My family and I just moved to town and we tried Fratellis for the first time tonight and i will say it was out of this world! I had the Risotto Pescatore (forgive my spelling) it was so good that I ate it all and the portion was big. My wife had Chicken Vodka Parmigiana and said it was the best she ever had, the chicken was just the right thickness. My kids enjoyed their pizza and got a kick out of watching it being made and cooked in the wood fired oven! we will certainly be returning! We can't wait to try the other dishes. I am not one to write reviews and I will never take the word from anyone else review. I believe we need to decide what we like on our own.... I say this place was great!!! 5 Stars from us.
Posted By: D R., 06 June, 2015
Yummy!!! Had the salmon last night and it was outrageous!! I have not had a bad meal here ever! The staff is great and the owners are so nice! We love it there.
Posted By: Corinne H., 29 May, 2015
The owners are fabulous and extremely nice. The pizza is fantastic and their other entrees are extremely tasty as well. Service is always nice and attentive and you will always feel welcome! The grandma pie is a personal favorite!!
Posted By: Steve R., 25 May, 2015
Fratellis is a great local pizzeria for people in Middletown New Jersey. Tonight my food was delivered in 25 minutes and the pizza was absolutely delicious as is tradition. If you're in the red bank: Middletown area you can count on fratellis to come through correctly with deliciousness and service.
Posted By: Chris Cuccia, 02 May, 2015
THE pizza place.
Posted By: Robin James, 10 April, 2015
I have to say we loved it! The food was delicious. I will return to try some more of their fabulous dinner specials.
Posted By: Sam C., 27 February, 2015
Just wanted to say how Thankful I am to the owners and staff for helping us in my families time of need. We had a family member pass away and we had the repast at Fratelli's and everything was absolutely wonderful and DELICIOUS!! Thank you!
Posted By: Nata J., 20 February, 2015
I loooove this place!!! The staff is polite and friendly, and their sicilian pizza is my absolute favorite.
Posted By: Emily R., 14 January, 2015
Soo good. The Grandma Pie = heaven.
Posted By: Bob S., 19 October, 2014
Authentic Italian menu at very competitive prices. The service is excellent you won't be rushed through your meal unless you're in a hurry. The portions are more than satisfying. So if you're not very hungry you'll be able to have a midnight snack. The food is so good there are a lot of returning customers so you kind of get to know The regular clientele. If Italian food is your desire this your the place. Enjoy!
Posted By: Sam C., 14 October, 2014
Just delicious! Went there this weekend and had the dinner special pollo bello. It's was fantastic! My wife had her usual chicken parm and he said it was the best she ever had.. My children had their grandma pie and brick oven margarita, they were also very happy. Will definitely return and bring my family and friends. Service was good.. Place was busy.. Very friendly!
Posted By: Dorothy F., 07 April, 2014
Good pizza. Definitely try their white pizza. Very reasonably priced as well.